31 Comments
User's avatar
Richard Mochelle's avatar

Excellent diagnosis Peter. I think it could have been said in far fewer words, however; it gets somewhat repetitive - like a boxer smashing gleefully into the opponent who has already been thoroughly beaten to the floor.

Hard to see how we get out of this mess. I've looked at the global coordinating, decision system you've proposed elsewhere and found it mind-bendingly complex (and I've completed a PhD).

My priority interest is in how we might practically serve as morally autonomous agents to engage democratically in constituting a cosmopolitan decision system - that takes into account your proposals alongside others - to be embedded in an experimental new civilisation species. So far, I've detected very little interest in such involvement. All very depressing!

rmochelle@gmail.com

Peter Joseph's avatar

When the "horse" doesn't actually die you have to keep beating it. :) I am working with Integral, so your decision-making concept is harmonious.

stopthe's avatar

This was a great read for someone who thought they knew more than they do.The gambling aspect was clear enough. But actions of certain investment vehicles was not clear to me.

An even wider view would take in the all the traditional gambling instruments from scratch tickets to mega millions, from full blown casinos to slot machines dotting resorts. It seems that an increasing number of people gauge all value according to wealth accrual. The means today is not by something you accomplish rather it is to place bet.The ends of wealth accumulation justifies any means. The least friction is the best path.

Sure the wealthiest gain by far the greatest gains from the sanctified investment schemes.But riches in themselves have become the most valuable cultural commodity.

This is the first time I have seen your Substack.

You have probably written about the opaqueness of engineered bonds and insurance products . I have a feeling that without Wall Streets pretensions about their necessity and a wall of legal protections, these markets would be seen as illegal frauds.

Johan Zijlstra's avatar

The cosmopolitan decision system I know of is called Simpol.

No, it's also not in place, but I like the concept of simultaneous policy!

This essay showed me the true nature of bonds. Why do we have nation-state bonds anyway?

stopthe's avatar

With a fiat money system it seems like a fiction needed to sustain faith in the value of our currency. There is no real reason I can see. Essentially we don’t need a financial system at least in this tortured form either. Most of the money is just traded not put to productive use.

Johan Zijlstra's avatar

Yeah, somehow it is thought that if nations would create money debt free and spend it into existence that this would automatically create inflation, while history has shown that money that is put to use to make infrastructure is beneficial to society...

David S.'s avatar

We definitely live in interesting times! How many of us will actually survive it?

Thank you, Peter, for another informative breakdown of our ecconomic nightmare and for your tenacity in the fight for a better world.

Andrew Jones's avatar

In fairness Peter has been kicking this horse long befor it was cool, keep it up Peter it will die one day or we all will.

Making Sense of the Madness's avatar

The mass of humanity or the corrupt: who dies first? Wanna place a polymarket bet? Lol

DZ's avatar

A great distillation of the unfortunate byproducts inherent in market dynamics.

Tim Hjersted's avatar

Peter I agree with your analysis and always wanted to ask you what you see as the personal alternative to investing in a retirement fund (SEP, IRA etc). Pending revolution with cradle-to-grave security (a goal I share), how should people use their savings for retirement?

Peter Joseph's avatar

Overthrow the system. Otherwise, you're gonna be trapped with inflation and increasingly fragile bonds as your only potential low risk option. There is no known investment strategy that isn't based upon Ponzi scheme structures. So you can roll the dice with the club and hope for the best in the traditional reality or you can just say fck it like I do and do nothing. If you have to do something - buy something physical like another house. But it's all financial and it's all fraudulent and it's all bullshit and it's all what you have to deal with if you care at all.

The Empathic Revolutionary's avatar

A universal right to exist closes the exception on which this strategy depends.

That right cannot depend on nationality, class, religion, political belief, economic usefulness, social approval, or obedience to authority. It belongs to every person by virtue of being human.

The First Law of Humanity arises from political necessity. Every system of domination depends on dividing the population into lives that deserve protection and lives that may be controlled, exploited, displaced, or destroyed. Cognitive warfare makes those divisions politically usable by directing fear, resentment, and blame toward selected groups until their mistreatment becomes publicly acceptable.

A universal right to exist closes the exception on which this strategy depends. No narrower principle can do so, because power can always redefine its boundaries and place new groups outside them. People do not need to admire one another, agree with one another, or care about one another personally. They must refuse to let authority turn human difference into permission for human sacrifice.

In this sense, the First Law is a natural law of free civilization. Once a population allows power to determine whose existence is legitimate, it has surrendered the only principle capable of protecting anyone from becoming its next target.

https://empathphilosophy.substack.com/p/universal-right-to-exist?r=62kuhy&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=web

Hrodtvitnir vanagandr's avatar

some ppl are so deeply hypnotized that they act exactly like mechanisms. all human behavior on the large, historical scale is so mechanical that it can be mathematically predicted. where mechanism is and mind is not, "war" happens. once the "killing" starts almost everybody goes mad with blood-lust and very, very few still dare to ask, what the heck are we doing this for? does it make any sense at all?

we all have to daily kill ourselves, often in the most gruesome manner possible, to become more than the bloke produced by the collision of accident, history, and genetics on the day we were born. going to knowledge wide awake, with fear, with respect, and with absolute assurance, patiently planing our jailbreak.

Great article! thank you!

(add howl)

*life contains tragedy, but life itself is not tragedy. the more you stir a turd, the more it stinks.

The Mind Awakened's avatar

Although I prefer to prove monetarism's obsolescence through philosophy, I appreciate seeing the math behind it. This essay makes it clear that money can exist only in a system that extracts profit.

Johan Zijlstra's avatar

That's not what I read, but I still like the essay nonetheless.

The Mind Awakened's avatar

Well, I am familiar with Peter Joseph. P.J goes deep into math and reason, and I prefer metaphilosphy, the laws of Nature. Both corroborate one another. That was my point.

Johan Zijlstra's avatar

You know that money has been used in history for other uses than extraction, right?

The Mind Awakened's avatar

Technology made extraction fatal... before that, humans couldn't destroy nature as fast... and money propelled technological advances because Money is a god, has always been. Socrates was quoted as saying that "a college degree obtained with money is worthless".

Money will always be used to trade/commodify life, and therefore stands against natural laws.